Choosing the right portable gas grill can be a tough decision, especially with so many options on the market. This review pits two popular contenders head-to-head: the Coleman RoadTrip 285 and the Weber Traveler. Both promise portability and convenient grilling, but their designs and performance differ significantly. We'll delve into the specifics of each grill, examining their build quality, features, ease of use, and overall value to help you determine which best suits your needs. This showdown will cover everything from initial setup and assembly to long-term durability and cooking performance, providing a comprehensive comparison to guide your purchasing decision.This in-depth comparison will highlight the strengths and weaknesses of both the Coleman RoadTrip 285 and the Weber Traveler. We'll explore the advantages of the Coleman's three-burner system for zone cooking against the Weber's compact single-burner design. We'll also examine the build quality and durability of each model, addressing crucial aspects like lid closure, assembly, and the overall user experience. Ultimately, this review aims to provide a clear and unbiased assessment to help you choose the portable gas grill that best fits your grilling style and expectations.
Pros And Cons
- Secure lid locking mechanism
- Porcelain-coated enamel inside
- Stainless steel construction
- Easy to transport
- Overall better build quality
- Only one burner
- Three burners
- Lower cost than Weber Traveler
- Cast iron grates
- Water trough
- Side shelves that slide in and out
- Three cooking zones
- Lid doesn't close properly due to non-adjustable riveted hinges
- Grates must be removed for transport (possibly)
- Construction quality issues (damaged unit received)
- Appears to be stamped metal, not stainless steel
- Water trough requires level ground
Read more: Top 10 Blue Rhino Gas Grills: Reviews & Buying Guide
Coleman RoadTrip 285: Initial Impressions and Issues
My journey with the Coleman RoadTrip 285 began with excitement, but quickly turned into frustration. I initially purchased a red model from my local hardware store, only to discover it was damaged upon arrival. Undeterred, I ordered a replacement from Amazon, hoping for a better experience.
Unfortunately, this second attempt revealed a significant design flaw: the lid wouldn't close properly. Despite attempts to adjust, the riveted hinges offered no solution. The misalignment was substantial, requiring me to remove bolts to even get the lid somewhat close.
A Closer Look at the Coleman RoadTrip's Features
Despite the lid issue, the Coleman RoadTrip boasts some interesting features. It offers three burners, a significant advantage over the Weber Traveler's single burner, promising better zone cooking capabilities. The grill features cast iron grates, and includes a water trough at the bottom. The purpose of the water trough isn’t entirely clear; it might help collect grease or even aid in temperature regulation.
One unexpected aspect is the removable side shelves. While convenient for cooking, they must be removed for transport, a minor inconvenience but something to keep in mind.
Weber Traveler: A Contender in Portability and Build
The Weber Traveler, in contrast, is a compact and well-engineered portable grill. Its construction is superior, featuring a robust aluminum frame and porcelain-enameled bowl. While possessing only a single burner, the design's simplicity contributes to its exceptional portability and ease of use.
The Weber Traveler’s lid locking mechanism is notably more secure than the Coleman’s, contributing to a more robust and reliable overall experience. The ease of setup and takedown is also a key differentiator.
Final Verdict: Which Grill Reigns Supreme?
The Coleman RoadTrip 285, while offering three burners and potentially better zone cooking, suffers from significant quality control issues. My experience with two defective units highlights concerns about its build quality and design. The lid misalignment is a major flaw.
The Weber Traveler, despite its higher price and single burner, wins due to its superior build quality, portability, and reliable design. While the three burners on the Coleman are appealing, the overall superior engineering of the Weber makes it the better choice for long-term use. The Coleman might suit occasional use, but for reliable performance and longevity, the Weber is unbeatable.