This comprehensive guide delves into the art of smoking a perfect brisket using the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker. We'll walk you through each step, from selecting the ideal brisket and trimming the fat cap, to mastering the art of applying a simple yet effective rub and achieving that coveted bark. We address the unique challenges presented by electric smokers, offering modifications to optimize airflow and enhance the smoking process. This guide is designed for both beginners seeking a delicious brisket and experienced pitmasters looking to refine their technique with the Masterbuilt.Learn how to overcome the moisture retention common in electric smokers and achieve a juicy, tender brisket with a beautiful bark. This guide provides detailed instructions on cooking temperature, wrapping techniques, and the critical resting period. Discover the secrets to consistently achieving restaurant-quality results at home, unlocking the full potential of your Masterbuilt Electric Smoker and producing a brisket worthy of any barbecue competition. Prepare to elevate your smoking game to the next level!
Pros And Cons
- High-quality brisket (USDA Choice, Prime, or Wagyu) results in a better product.
- A full packer cut (point and flat muscles attached) cooks more evenly and juicily.
- Proper trimming of fat cap to 1/4 inch thickness protects the brisket, adds flavor, and allows for good bark formation.
- Select-grade brisket lacks intramuscular fat, resulting in a less high-quality product.
- Using a cheaper brisket will not result in a high-quality product, regardless of cooking techniques.
- Too thick fat cap may result in unwanted fat and prevent good bark formation.
Read more: Weber BBQ Tool Set: 6-Piece Must-Have Kit
Selecting the Perfect Brisket
Choosing the right brisket is paramount for a successful cook. Forget cheap select grade; aim for at least USDA Choice, and ideally Prime or Wagyu for superior marbling and flavor. A full packer cut (around 10-15 pounds) with both point and flat muscles attached ensures a balanced, juicy result.

Look for a brisket with a continuous layer of soft, pillowy fat (the fat cap). This fat protects the meat during smoking and contributes to even cooking. Avoid briskets with hard, stiff fat, as this will need to be trimmed extensively.

When you’re at the store, take your time selecting the perfect piece of meat. Remember, quality ingredients will lead to superior results and an unforgettable meal. A little extra investment in a high-quality brisket is well worth the superior taste.
Trimming the Brisket
Unless your butcher has pre-trimmed it, your brisket will require some attention. Trim the fat cap down to about ¼ inch thickness. This leaves enough fat for protection and flavor, while still allowing for a good bark formation. Too much fat results in excessive grease and a lack of bark development.

Use a very sharp knife and carefully shave off layers of fat until you reach the desired thickness. It is helpful to freeze the brisket for about an hour beforehand to firm up the fat for easier trimming. Pay close attention to ensure you're not removing too much of the meat.
Proper trimming is key to a delicious outcome. The process might take some time and attention to detail, but the payoff is a superior cooking experience.
Applying the Rub
For authentic Texas-style brisket, the traditional rub is simply salt and pepper (a 50/50 ratio). While it may seem minimalistic, this classic combination delivers incredible flavor. Don't believe the hype about complicated rubs - this works incredibly well.

Evenly distribute the salt and pepper mixture over the entire brisket, starting with the fat cap side. There’s no need for a binder like mustard or oil. A simple shaker is all you need for perfect application.

After the salt and pepper, consider adding a teaspoon of Morton's Tender Quick for a characteristic pink smoke ring (optional but recommended for this electric smoker). Let the brisket rest at room temperature for 30 minutes to an hour to allow the rub to penetrate.

Preparing the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker
Achieving good bark in an electric smoker can be challenging. The Masterbuilt, while excellent, tends to retain moisture, hindering bark development. To improve airflow and create a better draft, remove the chip loader tray and install a 3-inch dryer vent.

Also, completely remove the exhaust vent to further enhance airflow and encourage bark formation. This setup helps combat the inherent moisture issues of electric smokers and enhances the final crust.

These modifications significantly improve the smoking process in the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker. Remember that modifications should be done carefully and safely.

Cooking the Brisket
Due to size constraints, the brisket needs to be cooked with the point and flat stacked in the Masterbuilt. Angle the point down towards the heat source (fat side down), as it’s thicker and cooks slower. This setup promotes even cooking.

Cook the brisket at 225°F. After about two hours, release excess steam to prevent it from interfering with bark formation. Spritz every hour after four hours, focusing on dry spots to encourage bark. Don't over-spritz; only spray dry areas.

Wrap the brisket in foil around 165-180°F internal temperature, depending on bark color and development. Adding a cup of beef consommé or stock enhances moisture and flavor. Then, increase the temperature to 275°F to speed up the cooking process.

Finishing and Slicing the Brisket
The brisket is done when it reaches 195-205°F internal temperature and probes tender like room-temperature butter in the thickest part of the flat. Do not rely solely on the point; ensure the flat is equally tender. Continue cooking until it meets this standard.

Rest the brisket for at least two hours after cooking. This allows the juices to redistribute, ensuring a more tender and juicy final product. Once rested, carefully slice the brisket against the grain using a sharp knife.

The final result should be a juicy, tender brisket with a perfect bark. This is achieved through careful attention to detail throughout the entire cooking process. Proper slicing technique helps maintain moisture and improve overall quality.
Conclusion: Is the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker Worth It?
The Masterbuilt Electric Smoker, with modifications, can produce an excellent Texas-style brisket. However, achieving optimal bark requires addressing its inherent moisture retention. By improving airflow, you can mitigate this issue and achieve a delicious result.

The modifications, while requiring effort, are worthwhile for enhancing the smoking process. The final product is a juicy, tender brisket with a beautiful bark that rivals the results of many offset smokers.
Overall, the Masterbuilt Electric Smoker is a valuable tool, especially with the described modifications. It allows for easier temperature control and consistent results, making it a great option for beginners and experienced pitmasters alike.