Choosing between a compact charcoal grill can be tough, but this review tackles the head-to-head comparison of two popular contenders: the Weber Smokey Joe and the Old Smokey 14". Both grills boast portability and affordability, making them perfect for small spaces, tailgating, or apartment living. However, subtle differences in design, build quality, and features ultimately lead to distinct grilling experiences. This detailed comparison explores the strengths and weaknesses of each grill, examining aspects like heat retention, ease of use, cleaning, and modification potential. We'll delve into the materials used, the cooking area, and the overall durability of each model.Ultimately, the decision of which grill reigns supreme comes down to personal preference and intended use. This review aims to provide you with a clear understanding of the nuances of each grill, allowing you to make an informed choice based on your specific grilling needs and priorities. We'll uncover which grill offers superior heat control, longevity, and ease of cleanup, ultimately guiding you towards the perfect compact charcoal grill for your backyard adventures.
Pros And Cons
- More headspace
- Possibility for indirect cooking with modifications
- Interchangeable grill parts with Weber Smokey Joe
- Lid does not fit tightly
- Thinner gauge steel
- Wear parts (tray) burn out quickly
- Portability
- Tight-fitting lid
- Durable porcelain enamel coating
- Ash tray to contain ash
- Less headspace than Old Smokey
- Smaller cooking capacity
Read more: 10 Best Commercial Charcoal Grills: A Buyer's Guide
A Look at the Contenders
This comparison pits two popular 14-inch charcoal grills against each other: the Weber Smokey Joe and the Old Smokey. Both are known for their compact size and portability, making them ideal for smaller spaces or tailgating. However, they differ in features and build quality, leading to distinct grilling experiences.
The Weber Smokey Joe boasts a classic, simple design with a focus on durability and ease of use. Its porcelain-enameled bowl and lid provide excellent heat retention and even cooking. The Old Smokey, while also compact, features a slightly different design and construction.
Price and Build Quality
Surprisingly, both grills were found to be priced similarly online at the time of this review. This makes the choice more about personal preference and desired features.
The Weber Smokey Joe's porcelain enamel is renowned for its longevity. In contrast, the Old Smokey utilizes steel with a coating, which might not last as long, although its design allows for some modifications to improve functionality. The Old Smokey proudly displays "Made in the USA", but the fine print reveals some imported parts.
Modifications and Upgrades
Both grills can be easily modified to enhance their performance. The reviewer added cheap stainless steel daisy wheels to the vents on the Old Smokey, and a lid thermometer, for improved temperature control.
For the Weber Smokey Joe, modifications were already in place; however, the reviewer mentioned that adding a similar daisy wheel and a thermometer would enhance temperature control and the overall grilling experience. These upgrades highlight the customizability of both models.
Grilling Performance and Features
The reviewer highlights that the Old Smokey offers more headroom, allowing for larger items like a small chicken to be cooked. The Weber Smokey Joe's compact design is more limited, ideal only for burgers, hot dogs and smaller cuts of meat.
Both grills utilize a simple charcoal grate system. However, the Old Smokey includes a removable ash tray, a feature absent in the Smokey Joe. This can make cleanup easier on the Old Smokey. The Weber Smokey Joe's lid fit was described as very snug, while the Old Smokey's had a looser fit.
Indirect Cooking and Interchangeability
The reviewer demonstrated the ability to achieve indirect cooking on both grills with custom-made heat deflectors. This suggests that even the smaller Weber Smokey Joe can handle more complex cooking methods.
Interestingly, the reviewer mentioned that some grill grates were interchangeable between the two models. This opens up possibilities for customization and upgrades, further showcasing the flexibility of both grills.
Conclusion: Which Grill Reigns Supreme?
Both the Weber Smokey Joe and the Old Smokey 14" offer excellent value and portability. The choice boils down to personal preference and priorities. The Weber Smokey Joe shines in its robust construction and tight-fitting lid, ensuring even heat distribution and better durability.
The Old Smokey, with its slightly larger cooking area and potential for modifications, provides more versatility, making it suitable for different types of cooking. Ultimately, the reviewer prefers the Weber Smokey Joe for its overall quality and longevity, but acknowledges that both grills are great options for backyard grilling needs.
