This review details my two-year experience with the Texas Original 20x40x20 offset smoker, covering its performance, build quality, and modifications I've made. Initially purchased for its size and included free shipping, this smoker has proven to be a reliable workhorse in my backyard. Over the past two years, I’ve made several upgrades to enhance functionality and performance, addressing minor initial shortcomings and ultimately improving its overall cooking capabilities. These modifications, along with an assessment of its inherent strengths and weaknesses, will be discussed in detail.My review will cover aspects ranging from the initial build quality and included features to the necessary modifications I implemented to optimize its performance. I will compare the Texas Original to other smokers I've owned, placing it within the context of the current market and considering its value proposition. Ultimately, I'll offer a definitive answer to the question: Would I buy this smoker again, knowing what I know now? And finally, I’ll discuss whether this smoker is the right choice for your barbecue needs.
Pros And Cons
- Fantastic smoker
- 20 by 20 firebox is plenty big
- Upgraded to thicker metal on stack and pipe
- Solid construction, no gaps
- Good weld quality
- Paint has held up well
- Good value considering free shipping
- Durable, will last a lifetime
- Quarter-inch steel
- Original thinner metal stack was dented
- Did not originally come with a handle on the top rack
- Price point may seem high initially (but shipping is included)
Read more: Weber Master Touch Review After Several Months of Use
Significant Upgrades and Modifications
Two years into owning my Texas Original 20x40x20 offset smoker, I've made several modifications. The original charcoal basket was replaced with a custom-built fire basket, improving the wood-burning aspect. I also fabricated a new grate and framed it for better functionality. The initial 20x20 firebox proved to be perfectly sized.
The stack, originally dented from shipping due to thinner metal, was replaced. The manufacturer seems to have improved the quality, using thicker, more durable metal in their current models. I extended the stack to be 90 degrees to the cook chamber, and added a square collector, visually similar to a fat stack smoker design, for enhanced smoke management.
Interior Enhancements and Accessories
Internally, I added two tuning plates to complement the original heat diffuser plate, ensuring even heat distribution throughout the cooking chamber. I also welded a handle onto the top rack for easier access. Two bottom grates (20x40) were added for more cooking space. A simple shelf underneath accommodates various tools.
The original cover was no longer suitable, so a Brazos cover from Academy Sports was purchased for approximately $40. It's durable and fits perfectly, even after two years of continuous use.
Build Quality and Performance
The smoker's weld quality is decent; there are no significant gaps. While not a high-end Shirley Fabrication smoker, it's a solid build. I added a reversed handle, inspired by Lang smokers, to the back for convenience. Over the past two years, this smoker has consistently performed well, holding up to regular use.
Comparison and Value
I've owned several smokers, including an Oklahoma Joe and a Horizon. This Texas Original holds its own in the upper mid-market segment, easily comparable to a Horizon. While the initial price may seem high, remember that free shipping is included, saving several hundred dollars, compared to competitors.
Considering the current high steel prices and shipping costs, the overall value of this smoker is excellent for what you get. My total costs including shipping (in North Carolina) and modifications were around $2600. A comparable new smoker might cost significantly more.
Final Verdict and Recommendations
Would I buy it again? Maybe. While I'd consider a Workhorse Pit now due to its similar price and features, the Texas Original Pit offers excellent value for a workhorse smoker. The build quality and performance are exceptional. I have no regrets buying it.
This smoker is durable and will last a lifetime. While the brand recognition could be improved, the smoker itself is robust, reliable, and provides a fantastic BBQ experience. If you are in the market for a smoker at a reasonable price point and can accommodate the size, this one is a great option!
